Of course, their story is far more complicated than the familiar Thanksgiving narrative. The Mayflower passengers included religious Separatists, other English settlers, and children traveling as servants or wards. They arrived in a region already inhabited by Indigenous peoples, including the Wampanoag, whose history extends far beyond their encounters with the English settlers.
But the names of these passengers offer a fascinating glimpse into the beliefs, traditions, and circumstances of the people who carried them.
![]() | |
|
Children of the Mayflower
The following names belonged to children who traveled aboard the Mayflower in 1620, along with one especially memorable addition born after the ship reached New England.
Some traveled with their parents, while others were servants, wards, or children placed in the care of other families. Their circumstances varied, and some of their stories remain uncertain.
I've listed each name only once, even when several children shared it. There were three girls named Mary, for example!
Girls Aboard the Mayflower
- Constance
- Damaris
- Desire
- Dorothy
- Elizabeth
- Elinor "Ellen"
- Humility
- Mary
- Priscilla
- Remember
Boys Aboard the Mayflower
- Bartholomew
- Edward
- Elias
- Francis
- Giles
- Henry
- Jasper
- John
- Joseph
- Oceanus
- Resolved
- Richard
- Robert
- Roger
- Samuel
- Truelove "Love"
- William
- Wrestling
And one very special arrival: Peregrine White, born aboard the Mayflower while it was anchored off the coast of present-day Massachusetts.
The Names That Tell a Story
Among these familiar classics are some real gems. These names don't just seem old-fashioned; they're exceptionally imaginative! And they tell us something about the people who chose them, whether it's a connection to faith, a meaningful event, or the circumstances of a child's birth.
Forget bonnets and oversized belt buckles for a moment. These names have stories to tell.
Oceanus Hopkins: Born during the Atlantic crossing, Oceanus received a name that memorialized the circumstances of his birth. It's an extraordinary example of a name functioning almost like a miniature family history. And what a gorgeous word name! Oceanus evokes the vast sea these passengers crossed, and I think it has a surprisingly contemporary sound.
Peregrine White: Born while the Mayflower was anchored in Provincetown Harbor, Peregrine received a name that seems especially fitting for the family's journey. It comes from Latin peregrinus, meaning "traveler," "foreigner," or "pilgrim." Today, we may associate Peregrine with the falcon, but the name's connection to travel and wandering makes it particularly meaningful here. And if you love the name but find it a little elaborate, there's always the lovely short form Perry.
Remember Allerton: The Mayflower passengers weren't simply taking a boat ride. For the Separatists, the voyage was closely connected to their search for religious freedom and the opportunity to establish a community shaped by their beliefs. Remember is a name that feels like an instruction, a prayer, or a memorial. It's easy to imagine how meaningful such a name might have been during a time of uncertainty and change.
Love (Truelove) Brewster: A perfect virtue name if there ever was one! Love embodies what every parent hopes to surround a child with. And—surprise!—this name belonged to a boy. Love is such a simple, beautiful word that I think it works wonderfully as a name. In fact, Love was always on my list of possible middle names for my daughter.
Wrestling Brewster: Love's brother had an equally memorable name, although perhaps a less immediately appealing one to modern ears! Wrestling likely reflects the family's religious beliefs, particularly the biblical story of Jacob wrestling with God. It also evokes the spiritual struggles that were central to Puritan religious life. I can't say Wrestling would make my list of usable baby names today, but it certainly inspires curiosity.
Beyond the Mayflower: Names from Puritan New England
I decided to take you all on a journey of our own. After the Mayflower's arrival, Plymouth Colony grew, more English settlers arrived, and other Puritan communities were established throughout New England.
And if you thought the Mayflower passengers had imaginative names, just wait! Here are some intriguing names documented by Alice Morse Earle in her book Child Life in Colonial Days, which you can read in its entirety online.
- Admire
- Believe
- Comfort
- Experience
- Freelove
- Hopestill
- Mehitable
- Preserved
- Reform
- Restore
- Silence
- Supply
- Temperance
- Thanks
- Tremble
- Truegrace
- Wait
These names sat alongside more familiar choices like Abel, Thomas, Ezekiel, Barnard, Elizabeth, Ruth, and Sarah.
We still use virtue names today, of course. And these names were chosen with as much Truelove (see what I did there?) that parents today have when choosing Grace, Faith, or Hope.
Names like Wait, Tremble, and Preserved may sound a little peculiar to modern ears, and that's what makes them delightfully fascinating. The Puritans lived in a world in which a child's name could express a prayer, a spiritual conviction, or a deeply held family value. Today's parents still like the thought, but perhaps dislike the pressure or corrective nature that some of those choices held.
Of course, not every Puritan child received an elaborate virtue name. Many families continued using familiar biblical and traditional English names. Still, these more unusual choices give us a wonderful glimpse into the creativity of early New England naming traditions.
Which Names Deserve a Second Look?
So, after traveling through a few centuries of naming history, which of these names could find a home on a modern birth certificate?
Personally, I like Constance, Priscilla, Jasper, and Peregrine. Remember is an intriguing possibility for parents who love unusual virtue names, while Oceanus feels surprisingly at home among today's adventurous nature names.
Even when a name isn't one we'd choose today (ermm Tremble), it can tell us something about the people who lived before us, the values they held, and the hopes they had for their children. The Mayflower passenger roster is only one small piece of a much larger and more complicated history, but it offers a fascinating window into the naming traditions of its time.
And who knows? Maybe somewhere out there is a future little Oceanus or Remember, just waiting to make an appearance.
Which of these names would you consider using today? Are there any that surprise you? And do you have a favorite unusual virtue name from history?


No comments:
Post a Comment